I did, but I do not believe that is the issue since it's not a color related issue but a sprite state issue.
This is how the background UIButton component looks right now for each of the buttons on my bar.

Now given 2 buttons A & B. Lets say Button A is currently on the "disabled" state. If I click Button B then A should be enabled and switch its sprite to the normal state, while button B should change to the "disabled" state. Like so:
Instead what occurs is that Button A stays using the "disabled" state sprite but responds to clicks while B shows disabled.
Head-scratching note: is that if I hover my mouse over the buttons, the sprites change to the correct states.